Whistle blowers: what people have been saying about the debate
Discussion about the Frontline Club/New Statesman debate on Saturday has continued in blogs and on Twitter, under #fcnsdebate.
The New Statesman‘s two-part coverage of the event plus video of all the speakers, photo library and live blog is here. Video of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange speaking, not surprisingly in favour of the motion that whistle blowers make the world a safer place is at the end of this post.
Journalist Patrick Smith, who has included the above widget showing all the #fcnsdebate has written an account of the evening, with audio, of each of the speakers here. He writes that where Assange “is on stronger ground…”
is on the effect Wikileaks has had in Asia, Africa and across the developing world. Certainly among cynical hacks in the London media jungle (or rather, thoses that don’t work for the Guardian), there is a feeling that the “cablegate” leaks didn’t contain much of interest. Though embarrassing for the US State Department, there was a lot of nonsense too, such as the revelation that French premier Nicolas Sarkozy once chased a rabbit around his office.
But Assange pointed out that the Indian national paper The Hindu has put cablegate leak-based stories on its front page 21 times in the last six weeks – Indian readers are fascinated by the revelations on Indian government corruption.
Here’s what other websites and blogs have had to say about the debate:
The Guardian picks up on Assange‘s claim that WikiLeaks is ‘more accountable than governments’
Dominic Ponsford on Press Gazette’s Wire, focuses on Assange‘s claim that WikiLeaks could have stopped the war in Iraq.
The Register headlines on Assange‘s claim that Google hits ‘prove’ WikiLeaks didn’t have the blood of Afghans on its hands.
Thinq focuses on Assange‘s mention of the Vietnam and Iraq wars and whether WikiLeaks might have prevented them, while Sefrew’s blog quotes ex MI5 agent Annie Machon who was invited to contribute during the debate:
If we lived in an ideal world where we had transparency, freedom of information and real democracy we wouldn’t need whistleblowers. We need some sort of protection for whistleblowers but until then we have WikiLeaks.
Finally, the hindustantimes remarks that on the fact that,
in a land of atheists, as close to 800 people queued outside Kensington Town Hall in west-central London to hear the words of God.
Picture credit: Sophia Spring