« back to Rob Crilly - African Safari home

 

Pirates Smuggle Somalia on to the Agenda

| 5

Johnny Depp as Jack Sparrow
It has become fashionable among some of my colleagues in Nairobi to express irritation at the level of interest the world is showing in Somalia's pirates. The argument is generally expressed by pointing out that Somalia has been a mess for 17 years, stands on the brink of a major humanitarian catastrophe and all of that is being ignored because hacks can throw around a few cliches about cutlasses and cannon. Then add in a few misguided descriptions of the pirates as modern day Robin Hoods providing a security service and the result is outrage from the new piracy experts. As Nick Wadhams puts it...
I hate to get all self-righteous, but c'mon, folks. As 52 NGO's said today, half of Somalia's 7 million people are in critical need of food aid. I thought the release was extraordinarily well-timed. Sobers you up a bit when you start feeling inclined to write another cute story about how you interviewed the pirates.
As usual, I take a more relaxed view. Who gives a stuff about Somalia any more? It has been a basketcase for 17 years and struggled through cycles of drought, famine and flooding while the gunmen continue to fight. Today it is a post-failed state that attracts world attention only when its Islamists threaten to take power. Millions of people need emergency aid just like they have done for almost two decades. News is news when it's new. Somalia's suffering is old hat. So if the pirates propel Somalia on to the news pages then that has to be a good thing. Plenty of people back home are hearing and thinking about Somalia for the first time probably since Black Hawk Down. The trick is to smuggle in some of the serious stuff just below your reference to Johnny Depp. See also the DRC's gorillas.

5 Comments

user-pic
Nick Wadhams | October 13, 2008 12:01 PM | Reply

Dearest African S.,



As usual, you distort my words and take me wildly out of context. I've come to expect nothing less from such a salty sea dog as yourself. My point is not that I'm irritated about the world showing interest in Somalia. My point is that some reporters who shall remain unnamed seem to have been more excited about trumpeting the fact that they snagged not-very-exclusive interviews with the pirates than pointing out that the pirates are killing the Somali people.



With great admiration for your blog and your writing more generally,

Nick

user-pic
Anonymous | October 13, 2008 12:13 PM | Reply

I'm a journalist Nick - that's my job.



Your point, as I understood it, was that all the rest of us are missing the point by writing about the pirates rather than the food crisis... We shouldn't glorify a bunch of gangsters simply because they ride around in boats.



My point is that no-one cares about the food crisis. Meanwhile piracy occupies a unique position in the histories of many seafaring nations, produced a rich vein of literature and music, and - in your homeland - even a series of theme park rides. We all love a good pirate yarn. The responsible thing is not to get po-faced about declining journalistic standards, but use it to get people talking about the factors behind it.



With great appreciation for your willingness to take up cudgels and get a proper feud going

Rob

user-pic
Nick Wadhams | October 13, 2008 2:27 PM | Reply

Po-faced! I've never been one to quibble over journalistic standards, unless they have to do with the senseless victimization of George Obama.



I don't object to journalists writing about the pirates. I have written about the pirates myself. And yes, it can be awfully difficult to get to the end of a story about Somalia's food crisis. In fact, we agree. I object, A. Safari, because people aren't writing about the factors behind the piracy or the fact that the pirates are partly responsible for the food crisis in Somalia. Reporters are not going terribly far beyond the "Hey! Pirates! Wacky!" line when this story gives them a great opportunity to do so. And then, of course, they crow and crow about their "exclusive" pirate interviews.



Incidentally, PotC is featured at every Disney park in the world. If the UK had a Disney park, PotC would be there too. In fact, I have no idea why the UK hasn't got a Disney park yet. Maybe it's still recovering from the Millennium Experience.



Finally, aside from "Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum," name me one pirate song. Just one. Rich vein of literature, yes, but music?

user-pic
Tom Schaffer | October 13, 2008 3:21 PM | Reply

I agree that the piracy-crisis should be used as an anchor to get people informed about the food-crisis. Let me add one thing to that: It's the pirates' activities, which partially prevent the World Food Programme from delievering food to those who starve in Somalia, since their ships cannot be considered safe anymore. At least that's what I heard some weeks ago.

user-pic
Anonymous | October 13, 2008 3:32 PM | Reply

Nick,

Barrett's Privateers (I'm currently listening to the original Stan Rogers version on the seminal Fogarty's Cove - hat tip to Toaf).


What do you think?